TV Hulk Logo
Explained

Is The Conjuring Based on a True Story? The Perron Family Case

Miranda Davies ·
An old stone farmhouse on a grassy hillside beneath dark storm clouds and misty mountains

Photo: eberhardgross via Freepik

Yes and no. The Conjuring (2013) is based on real people: the Perron family, who moved into a farmhouse in Rhode Island in 1971, and the paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren. But the supernatural events are claims, not established facts, and the film changes a lot of what the family says happened. The film was marketed as “based on a true story,” according to Wikipedia. A more accurate description would be “based on a true family’s account of a haunting.”

Key Takeaways

  • The Perron family and the Warrens are real. The Perrons say they experienced paranormal activity in their Rhode Island farmhouse in the 1970s.
  • The haunting has never been independently verified. Skeptics question the Warrens’ work in general.
  • The exorcism at the end of the film did not happen, though Andrea Perron describes a séance in her books.
  • Bathsheba Sherman, the film’s witch, was a real woman, but local records do not support the film’s story about her.

What the Film Says

Directed by James Wan, with a screenplay by Chad Hayes and Carey W. Hayes, The Conjuring stars Vera Farmiga and Patrick Wilson as Lorraine and Ed Warren, and Lili Taylor and Ron Livingston as Carolyn and Roger Perron. Warner Bros. released it in the US on July 19, 2013.

The story follows the Perrons as they move into an old farmhouse and are terrorized by a malevolent presence. The Warrens are called in, and the film builds to an exorcism in the basement.

The Real Perron Family

Roger and Carolyn Perron moved into the farmhouse in Burrillville, Rhode Island, in 1971, with their five daughters. Their house is in the area of Harrisville, and the family says they began experiencing paranormal phenomena soon after.

The oldest daughter, Andrea Perron, who was a teenager at the time, told the family’s story in a three-book series called House of Darkness House of Light, which began publishing in 2011. According to the Providence Journal, the movie “tells a fictionalized version” of that account. The family left the house in 1980.

It is important to be clear about what the books are. They are the family’s recollections, written decades later. They are not independent documentation of the events.

The Warrens

Ed Warren (1926 to 2006) and Lorraine Warren (1927 to 2019) were American paranormal investigators. In 1952 they founded the New England Society for Psychic Research. Ed described himself as a demonologist and Lorraine as a clairvoyant.

Ed died in 2006, years before production began; Lorraine served as a consultant on the film and appears briefly in it. Wikipedia says the Hayes brothers’ revisions moved the story’s point of view from the Perrons to the Warrens.

In real life, the Warrens were minor figures in the Perron story. The Providence Journal reports that they were thrown out of the house by Roger Perron. Andrea Perron has described a séance in a downstairs room, during which she says her mother was levitated and thrown into the next room.

What the Film Changed

In the filmIn the record
A climactic exorcism in the basementNo exorcism took place. A séance did, according to Andrea Perron’s books
The Warrens are the heroes who save the familyThe Warrens were a minor part of the family’s story
Bathsheba Sherman is a witch who sacrificed her child and killed herselfShe died in Burrillville in 1885 at age 73, and her son lived another 18 years
The house is a three-story home with a columned porchThe real farmhouse dates to the 1730s and looks very different
The story is set in Harrisville, Rhode IslandThe film was shot in North Carolina

The Providence Journal reports that the house in the movie is in North Carolina, while the real one is a plain, older farmhouse in Rhode Island.

Bathsheba Sherman

The witch at the center of the film is based on a real woman. According to the Providence Journal, the real Bathsheba Sherman did not die by suicide after sacrificing a child, as the film shows. She died in Burrillville in 1885 and her son, Herbert, lived into his fifties. The story that she was a witch who sacrificed her baby comes from the Warrens’ account of the case, according to Wikipedia.

You should treat the witch story as a legend attached to a real woman’s name. It is not established history.

What Skeptics Say

The Warrens’ record is disputed, and the case for treating the Perron haunting as fact rests largely on the family’s and the Warrens’ own accounts.

  • Steven Novella and Perry DeAngelis of the New England Skeptical Society investigated the Warrens in the 1990s. A 1997 Connecticut Post interview, cited on Wikipedia, reports that they found the Warrens pleasant but concluded that their evidence was “blarney,” and that they were not doing good scientific investigation.
  • Skeptical investigators Joe Nickell and Benjamin Radford concluded that two better-known Warren cases, Amityville and the Snedeker house in Connecticut, did not happen as claimed. Those are separate cases from the Perron case, but they are often raised when people discuss the Warrens’ reliability.
  • Skeptics point out that old wooden farmhouses creak, shift and cause drafts, which can explain some reported sounds. Others argue that decades-old family memories can change over time.

Believers point to the Perron family’s consistent accounts over many years and the sincerity of those involved. Neither side can prove its case. What can be said is that no independent evidence has confirmed a supernatural cause.

So, Is It a True Story?

The people, the house and the family’s claims are real. The paranormal events are claims, and the film’s most dramatic scenes, including the exorcism and the witch’s backstory, are fiction or legend. It is fair to say the film is inspired by a real case, but you should not treat it as a documentary.

If you are watching other horror films for their real-life locations, see our guide to where The Shining was filmed. For other films with a “based on a true story” claim worth checking, read about Fargo and the twist in Shutter Island.

Frequently Asked Questions

Was The Conjuring a true story?

Partly. The Perron family and the Warrens are real, and the Perrons say they experienced a haunting. The paranormal events are unverified claims, and the film changes many details.

Did the exorcism in The Conjuring really happen?

No. The Providence Journal reports that the climactic exorcism did not happen. Andrea Perron describes a séance, not an exorcism, in her books.

Was Bathsheba Sherman a real person?

Yes, but the film’s story about her is not supported. She died in 1885 at age 73, and her son lived another 18 years.

Where did the real Perron family live?

In a farmhouse in Burrillville, Rhode Island, in the village area of Harrisville, from 1971 to 1980. The house is private property, so please respect the owners.

Are the Warrens considered reliable?

Their work is disputed. Skeptics such as Steven Novella, Joe Nickell and Benjamin Radford have criticized their investigations, while the Warrens maintained that their cases were genuine.

Video: The Conjuring - Official Main Trailer [HD] from Warner Bros. on YouTube.

Sources

Miranda Davies

Written by Miranda Davies

Film & TV Enthusiast

Hi, my name is Miranda Davies, and I’ve loved film and television all of my life. Some of my earliest memories involve me and family or friends catching the latest movies, or reclining on the couch to catch some awesome television, and I want to share that passion with fellow fans like you! The best way to celebrate film and television is to chat about it with people as equally passionate as you, so this website will be dedicated to being a hub for those that want to chat about their obsessions in a safe and welcoming environment that is fun to visit!

More about the author