TV Hulk Logo
Explained

Is Fargo Based on a True Story? The Truth Behind the Claim

Miranda Davies ·
An empty road running through snowy fields and frosted pine trees under a pale winter sky

Photo: wirestock via Freepik

No. The Coen brothers’ Fargo (1996) opens with a card saying it is a true story, but the plot and characters are fiction, and the claim is part of the joke. The film borrows one grisly detail from a real crime, and the FX series repeats the same opening card for each season’s invented story.

Key Takeaways

  • The “This is a true story” card at the start of Fargo is a storytelling device, not a statement of fact.
  • Joel Coen has said the film was based loosely on an actual criminal event but that the characters were fully imagined.
  • The 1986 murder of Helle Crafts in Connecticut is often cited as the inspiration for the wood chipper scene.
  • Takako Konishi, a Japanese woman found dead in Minnesota in 2001, did not go looking for the film’s buried money. That story is an urban legend.

What the Opening Card Says

Fargo begins with white text on a black screen. It says the events took place in Minnesota in 1987, that names were changed at the request of the survivors, and that out of respect for the dead the rest is told exactly as it occurred. Wikipedia notes that a version of the card was digitally added to the film’s 2003 special edition DVD.

None of that is true. The characters, including car salesman Jerry Lundegaard (William H. Macy), pregnant police chief Marge Gunderson (Frances McDormand), and kidnappers Carl Showalter (Steve Buscemi) and Gaear Grimsrud (Peter Stormare), are invented. The film was released on March 8, 1996, and won two Oscars, for McDormand’s performance and for the Coens’ original screenplay.

Snopes looked into the claim in 1998 and concluded that it was a prank of the sort the Coens enjoy, according to Wikipedia. The film also ends with a standard note that its characters are fictitious.

What the Coen Brothers Have Said

The Coens have been open that the “true story” label is a device. According to an MTV interview from 2005 cited by Wikipedia, they said they based the script on an actual criminal event but wrote a fictional story around it. Joel Coen said they weren’t interested in strict fidelity to the real case. The basic events match, he said, but the characterizations were fully imagined.

He also said that claiming a story is based on a real event gives filmmakers permission to do things an audience might not otherwise accept. In 1996, Wikipedia notes, he told a reporter that the real murders had not happened in Minnesota, despite what the card says.

Some Minnesotans suspected the plot was inspired by a 1963 case involving a St. Paul attorney, T. Eugene Thompson, who was convicted of hiring a man to murder his wife. The Coens said they had never heard of him. After Thompson died in 2015, Joel Coen said the story in Fargo was completely made up, according to the New York Times obituary cited by Wikipedia.

The Real Crime Behind the Wood Chipper

The nearest thing to a real source is the case of Helle Crafts. She disappeared on November 18, 1986, from her home in Newtown, Connecticut, after returning from a flight. Her husband, Richard Crafts, was an Eastern Air Lines pilot who also worked as a part-time police officer.

Investigators concluded that Crafts killed her and put her remains through a wood chipper. Remains and a chainsaw with traces of hair were found at the shore of Lake Zoar. A first trial ended in a mistrial in 1988, and a second jury found him guilty in November 1989. He was sentenced to 50 years. Wikipedia describes the case as Connecticut’s first murder conviction without the victim’s body.

The special edition DVD of Fargo says the case inspired the film, particularly the scene where Carl is put through a wood chipper. Beyond that image, the Crafts case has little in common with the movie. It happened in Connecticut, involved no kidnapping plot or car dealership, and the people involved are not the film’s characters.

The Takako Konishi Urban Legend

The most persistent myth about Fargo involves Takako Konishi, a Tokyo office worker. In November 2001, a bow hunter found her body in a field outside Detroit Lakes, Minnesota. She had traveled from Minneapolis through Bismarck and Fargo, North Dakota, before reaching Detroit Lakes.

News reports soon claimed she had come to the United States to find the money Carl buries in the snow in the film, believing it was real. That story is false. According to Wikipedia, it grew out of a misunderstanding with a police officer in Bismarck. She repeated a word that sounded like “Fargo” and pointed to a drawing of a road and a tree. An officer who had seen the film guessed that she was looking for the film’s money, and attempts to correct the idea failed. Media outlets then spread a distorted version of the story.

What police actually concluded was very different. Konishi had lost her job when her Tokyo travel agency went bankrupt and had been struggling. Police concluded that she intended to take her own life. The coroner could not determine an exact cause of death, and police considered exposure to the cold to be the most plausible cause. The evidence included a suicide note to her parents and a long phone call the night before.

If you are struggling, the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline is available in the US by calling or texting 988.

Konishi’s story has been retold in the 2003 short documentary This Is a True Story by Paul Berczeller, who also wrote a Guardian article about her, and in the 2014 film Kumiko, the Treasure Hunter, which is fictional. The legend shows how the film’s opening card could escape the screen and become tangled up with a real person’s life.

The FX Series and Its True Story Cards

The FX anthology series Fargo, created by Noah Hawley, uses the same device. According to Wikipedia, every episode opens with a card in the same style, naming a place and year, saying the names were changed and claiming the rest is told as it occurred.

SeasonAiredSetting
12014Minnesota and North Dakota, 2006 to 2007
22015Luverne, Minnesota, Fargo and Sioux Falls, 1979
32017Mostly Minnesota, 2010 to 2011
42020Kansas City, Missouri, 1950 to 1951
52023 to 2024Minnesota and North Dakota, late 2019

None of the seasons is a documented case. Hawley has said the device let him tell stories in a new way, and at a 2017 festival he asked what the words “true story” even mean, saying he wanted to take the idea apart in season 3.

So What Is Fargo, Really?

Fargo is a work of fiction dressed as a case file. The Coens used a real, grisly crime for one image, borrowed the tone of a true-crime story, and let the card do the rest. If you like checking how much of a film is real, see our guide to Titanic’s true story, or read about the twist in Shutter Island. If you enjoy the series’ mix of crime and dark humor, our list of shows like Broadchurch has other crime dramas worth a look.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does Fargo say it’s a true story?

The Coens used the claim as a device. Joel Coen has said a “based on a real event” label gives filmmakers permission to do things audiences might not otherwise accept.

Did the wood chipper scene really happen?

Not in the way the film shows it. The Helle Crafts case in Connecticut in 1986 involved a wood chipper, and the film’s special edition DVD says that case inspired the scene.

Was Jerry Lundegaard a real person?

No. Jerry is a fictional character, and no real person matches his plot.

Did Takako Konishi go to find the money from Fargo?

No. That is an urban legend that grew out of a misunderstanding with a police officer and was spread by media reports.

Is the FX series Fargo a true story?

No. Each season is a fictional story with a “true story” card in the same style as the film.

Sources

Miranda Davies

Written by Miranda Davies

Film & TV Enthusiast

Hi, my name is Miranda Davies, and I’ve loved film and television all of my life. Some of my earliest memories involve me and family or friends catching the latest movies, or reclining on the couch to catch some awesome television, and I want to share that passion with fellow fans like you! The best way to celebrate film and television is to chat about it with people as equally passionate as you, so this website will be dedicated to being a hub for those that want to chat about their obsessions in a safe and welcoming environment that is fun to visit!

More about the author