TV Hulk Logo
Movies

Movies Like Knives Out: 12 Clever Whodunits to Watch

Miranda Davies ·
A grand wood-panelled staircase with red carpet and carved banisters inside an old castle mansion

Photo: frimufilms via Freepik

Knives Out (2019), written and directed by Rian Johnson, sends Daniel Craig’s detective Benoit Blanc into a wealthy family’s mansion after a novelist’s death. Fans love the large cast of suspects, the twists and the sense of fun. These twelve films offer the same pleasures, from vintage puzzle mysteries to modern comedies. For the closest match, start with Clue.

Key Takeaways

  • Clue, See How They Run and Game Night are the funniest picks.
  • Gosford Park, Murder on the Orient Express and And Then There Were None focus on a closed circle of suspects.
  • The Last of Sheila and Sleuth are clever puzzle mysteries from the 1970s.
  • A Haunting in Venice and The Hateful Eight take a darker route.

What Makes Knives Out Special

Knives Out works because it takes the classic Agatha Christie setup, a wealthy family and a mysterious death, and gives it a modern twist. After the death of crime novelist Harlan Thrombey (Christopher Plummer), a private detective named Benoit Blanc, played by Daniel Craig with a Southern drawl, is hired by an anonymous client to investigate. Ana de Armas, Chris Evans, Jamie Lee Curtis, Toni Collette and Don Johnson fill out the family.

Its pleasures are specific: a cast that is clearly enjoying itself, a mansion full of secrets, jokes that land without undercutting the plot, and a script that plays fair with the audience. Johnson has cited Christie as an influence, and the film is full of nods to her.

The picks below follow different strands of that appeal. Some are direct ancestors, like the classic Christie adaptations, while others take the mystery in a funnier or darker direction. We have left out the Knives Out sequels so you can see what else the genre has to offer.

Clue (1985)

Jonathan Lynn directs a mansion full of eccentric guests, secret identities and shifting accusations. Tim Curry leads a cast that includes Eileen Brennan, Madeline Kahn, Christopher Lloyd and Lesley Ann Warren.

It is based on the board game, and its brisk comedy and crowd of colorful suspects give you the same pleasure of trying to spot the culprit before the reveal.

The Last of Sheila (1973)

Herbert Ross directs James Coburn as a producer who invites a group of Hollywood acquaintances aboard his yacht for a game built around their secrets, a year after his wife’s death. Richard Benjamin, Dyan Cannon, Raquel Welch, Ian McShane and James Mason co-star.

The screenplay was written by Anthony Perkins and Stephen Sondheim, and its clue-heavy plot rewards close attention.

Sleuth (1972)

Joseph L. Mankiewicz directs Laurence Olivier as a mystery novelist and Michael Caine as his wife’s lover, locked in a battle of wits inside a country house.

With only two actors and one location, it is a showcase for twisty plotting and theatrical showmanship.

Gosford Park (2001)

Robert Altman sets a murder at a 1930s English country estate during a weekend shooting party, watched from both the wealthy guests’ side and the servants’ below stairs. Maggie Smith, Michael Gambon, Kristin Scott Thomas, Ryan Phillippe and Kelly Macdonald are among the cast.

Its sharp look at class and hidden resentments will appeal if you liked the family dynamics in Knives Out.

Murder on the Orient Express (1974)

Sidney Lumet directs Albert Finney as Hercule Poirot, who investigates a murder on a snowbound train. Lauren Bacall, Ingrid Bergman, Sean Connery and Anthony Perkins are among the passengers.

A classic detective, a famous cast and a closed circle of suspects make it a fitting choice for a Benoit Blanc fan.

And Then There Were None (1945)

René Clair directs Barry Fitzgerald, Walter Huston, Louis Hayward and June Duprez in an adaptation of Agatha Christie’s novel. Ten strangers arrive on an isolated island and start to be picked off one by one.

It has the closed-circle tension that makes a suspect-filled house so satisfying.

See How They Run (2022)

Tom George directs Sam Rockwell as Inspector Stoppard and Saoirse Ronan as Constable Stalker, investigating a murder in London’s West End in the 1950s. Adrien Brody co-stars.

The theater setting, the mismatched partners and a playful nod to the genre make it an easy fit.

A Haunting in Venice (2023)

Kenneth Branagh directs and stars as Hercule Poirot, who is in retirement in Venice when a séance at a palazzo ends in murder. Tina Fey, Michelle Yeoh, Jamie Dornan and Kelly Reilly co-star.

It is a darker, more atmospheric take on the detective story, with a small group of suspects and a spooky mood. If you enjoy mysteries where the truth takes time to emerge, you may also like our Shutter Island ending explained guide, but only after seeing the film.

The Kid Detective (2020)

Evan Morgan directs Adam Brody as a once-celebrated child detective who is now a washed-up adult private investigator. A client played by Sophie Nélisse asks him to investigate her boyfriend’s murder.

It mixes dry humor with a melancholy portrait of fading fame, giving the whodunit a fresh angle.

Kiss Kiss Bang Bang (2005)

Shane Black directs Robert Downey Jr. as a small-time thief who is mistaken for an actor, and Val Kilmer as a private detective. Michelle Monaghan co-stars.

The narration is full of jokes and the plot twists constantly, making it a good pick for a comic mystery with a lot of voice.

Game Night (2018)

John Francis Daley and Jonathan Goldstein direct Jason Bateman and Rachel McAdams as a couple whose game night turns into what looks like a real kidnapping. Kyle Chandler co-stars.

The characters keep trying to work out what is real and what is staged, which makes it a lighter pick for a group watch.

The Hateful Eight (2015)

Quentin Tarantino directs Samuel L. Jackson, Kurt Russell and Jennifer Jason Leigh in a western set in a remote mountain stopover during a blizzard, where mistrust and violence build.

It is much harsher than Knives Out, but the closed-room mystery thread will suit fans of the genre.

How to Choose by Tone

Mysteries come in different moods, and Knives Out balances several of them: it is funny, but it also takes its puzzle seriously. If the humor was your favorite part, Clue, See How They Run and Game Night put jokes first. If you liked the polished, old-fashioned plotting, try Murder on the Orient Express, And Then There Were None or Sleuth, which are all built around clever reveals.

If you enjoyed the social commentary about money and class, Gosford Park does it best, using a murder as a way to look at the people upstairs and downstairs. For something more atmospheric, A Haunting in Venice adds a spooky edge. Most of these work well as a group watch, since half the fun is guessing the culprit together.

Which Mystery Should You Pick?

  • Breezy ensemble puzzle: Clue.
  • Clue-heavy secrets: The Last of Sheila.
  • Country-house class drama: Gosford Park.
  • Modern, funny detective story: See How They Run or Game Night.
  • Darker mood: A Haunting in Venice or The Hateful Eight.

Frequently Asked Questions

What movie is most similar to Knives Out?

Clue is the closest for its comic tone, large cast of suspects and mansion setting. Gosford Park is a good choice if you like a grand house with secrets below stairs.

Are there older movies with a similar whodunit feel?

Yes. The Last of Sheila (1973), Sleuth (1972), Murder on the Orient Express (1974) and And Then There Were None (1945) are all classic puzzle mysteries.

Which whodunits mix murder and comedy?

Clue, See How They Run, Kiss Kiss Bang Bang and Game Night all combine crime with humor.

What should I watch for a closed-circle mystery?

Murder on the Orient Express (a snowbound train) and And Then There Were None (an isolated island) are the classic choices, while Clue offers a comic take.

Sources

Miranda Davies

Written by Miranda Davies

Film & TV Enthusiast

Hi, my name is Miranda Davies, and I’ve loved film and television all of my life. Some of my earliest memories involve me and family or friends catching the latest movies, or reclining on the couch to catch some awesome television, and I want to share that passion with fellow fans like you! The best way to celebrate film and television is to chat about it with people as equally passionate as you, so this website will be dedicated to being a hub for those that want to chat about their obsessions in a safe and welcoming environment that is fun to visit!

More about the author